Cayuga Lake Creamery

Reviews about Cayuga Lake Creamery

• 5 / 5

  By Edward Smith
  Great flavors! Will definitely stop here again
  February 02, 2017
• 5 / 5

  By Avery McGuire
  Set just above Cayuga lake about 17miles from Ithaca, this place makes for a great destination for a weekend bike ride. High quality ice cream in a beautiful location, what more can you ask for?
  December 16, 2016
• 2 / 5

  By Jessica Weber
  OK ice cream but they need help with business operations. We showed up after 9pm on a Sunday. There were hardly any parking spots and most people we waiting for ice cream still. We had to wait at least 30 minutes for 2 dishes of simple ice cream because the lack of/slowness of staff. Of the 5 groups of people getting their orders before us there were 4 mistakes, one girl's ice cream was even forgotten and all of her friends finished and were ready to leave before she even got hers.
  
  My boyfriend ordered 2 flavors, no toppings and was really looking forward to the rum raisin because you don't see it often. We got ours to go and by the time he got to the "rum raisin" turns out it was their "white gold" flavor with cookie dough and white chocolate. He was so sad!
  October 04, 2016
• 4 / 5

  By Katrina Browne
  Great ice cream and friendly staff. I prefer to get it at green street pharmacy tho because the creamery overly chills they're otherwise fantastic product. Still 100x better than purity.
  June 21, 2016